Sunday, 25 February 2018

Measurement techniques for precision bearing balls

While rebuilding the Eagle surface grinder, I have to refurbish the spindle bearings. One of the challenges is to select matching bearing balls as accurately as possible.

Googling around, I could not find any information on how to do this with simple tools in the home shop. Some commercial methods which come to mind are using an optical comparator or 3d laser scanner. While taking myself and the dogs for a walk this morning at 5:30, I realised, like many times before; the old school machinists did not have all the fancy measuring equipment we have noways, yet managed to build very accurate and precise machines.  The idea of tolerance measurement similar to how snap gauges work came to mind.

To do this one has to measure the ball diameter. There are a few methods I can come up with to do
this. The intention is to measure diameter as accurately as possible, not just variations in the Lot or precision.


Tool Method Accuracy Repetability Issues
Micrometer place the ball between the anvil and measure Good Fair Measuring Force
Dial indicator Capture ball on stand, compare height of balls. Relative Good Allignment
Slip Gauge Build gate on surface plate with high and then low tolerance,
roll balls through the gate
Best Best Cleanliness


In a previous post I have described the calculations and selection of ball diameter. For reference, I am working with Grade 10 Balls, 13/32" or 10.31875mm



Grade Sphericity [mm] Lot diameter variation [mm] Nominal ball diameter tolerance [mm] +/- Maximum surface roughness (Ra) [µm]
10 0.00025 0.00025 0.0013   0.025

My method will firstly select balls which roll under the gauge block stack bridge setup for the high tolerance level of 10.32005mm, and then from this selection set, select the balls which do not pass under the low tolerance stack of 10.31745 mm. This is the simplest, and most accurate and precise method I could think of  for the home shop machinist.

Great resource with lots of useful information:
http://www.precisionballs.com/Ball_diameter_Calibration.php
http://www.precisionballs.com/Ball_Diameter_Errors.php

No comments:

Post a Comment

Chipmaster Gear Cutting

  Calculate all the possible gear combinations for the gear selector to cut a 15TPI thread: Imperial TPI C 5 24 20 Imperial TPI ...